California – the land of sunshine, surf, and irony so thick you could pave a road with it. For years, the state has been obsessed with pushing electric vehicles (EVs) on its residents. 1) Generous rebates? Check. 2) Tax credits? Double check. 3) Special access to HOV lanes? You bet! And it worked. Californians embraced EVs with enthusiastic idealism. Meanwhile, gas tax revenue quietly kept the wheels turning – literally – by paying for road repairs, bridges, & public transit. But now that fewer people are fueling-up at the pumps, California’s cash cow is running empty. To fix it, the state has come up with a brilliant solution: Tax EV owners. Yep, the very same people they just incentivized… they’re now taxing.
From Hero to Villain in Record Time…
California spent years rolling-out the red carpet for electric vehicles, offering incentives that felt more like bribes. It worked so well that the gas tax, which was footing-the-bill for infrastructure, is now collecting dust. Turns out, fewer people burning gas means fewer $$$ to fix the potholes and road wear-&-tear that heavy EVs amplify.
But instead of rethinking its approach, California has decided to charge EV owners an annual fee to make up the difference. The pitch is that it’s fair since EV drivers also use the roads. To EV owners though, it feels more like being handed a bill at the end of a free trial. You were promised green sustainable glory… and now you’re paying for the privilege of believing the hype.
Other States Are Taking Notes…
California’s dilemma isn’t happening in a vacuum. Other states, and even entire countries, are watching this play out… trying to avoid the same trap. Oregon, for example, has been experimenting with a mileage-based road tax. In Europe, some governments are testing higher registration fees for EVs. Everyone’s asking the same question: How do you keep the roads in good shape when the main funding-source is evaporating?
Instead of taxing California residents…
For an EV that politicians just recently promised would SAVE them things (like money, gas, & the planet), maybe states should start by auditing their budgets. I’m no accountant, but I’d bet my next tank of gas you’d find some spare change there. Of course, that would require admitting some government-spending might not be as essential as they claim.
The Bigger Picture & the Grid…
Even if California gets this EV tax right, there’s a bigger issue lurking in the shadows: The power grid. For all the push & propaganda towards electric everything, California’s grid struggles to even keep-up with current demand in a heatwave. Taxing EVs becomes an even bigger frustration when you can’t even charge them on demand. It’s foreshadowing more broken promises, even more taxing, and potentially more restrictions on Californias’ freedoms. All so politicians can fix the very problems they created.
And let’s not ignore the obvious… because it may not be obvious to all. EVs are significantly heavier than internal combustion vehicles, primarily due to the batteries. For example, just the battery alone in a Rivian can weigh 2,000lbs, which is about as heavy as an entire old Miata. Heavier vehicles result in more stress on roads & bridges. And that leads to – you guessed it – more money needed for repairs & infrastructure. The EV tax might put a Band-Aid on the budget, but it doesn’t address the long-term reality.
So what Comes Next?
California’s EV tax is a cautionary tale about how quickly good intentions can backfire when the planning doesn’t match the ambition. Other states will likely face similar challenges, but there’s still time to rethink how we fund roads with more & more EVs on them. Whatever the case – sticking with the old gas tax model while EVs take over the roads isn’t gonna to cut it.
Article by Saddlebrook
•Get the free S3 Magazine app• (Apple)
•Get the free S3 Magazine app• (Android)
